If you've been following my page for quite some time now, you probably remember that I visited Tony Boys in Livingston two years ago. However, Tony Boys recently invited me back to try more of their tasty sandwiches. This time though, I visited their Montville location, as it is the closest branch to me. Besides the locations in Livingston and Montville, they also have one in Madison, and another one soon in Montclair.
When I went to Tony Boys this time, I tried various sandwiches. The first one I had was the '#10,' which came with fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, and balsamic. This sandwich comes with chicken cutlets or eggplant, and I got mine with the chicken. The sandwich was delicious and had tons of flavor between the chicken, mozzarella, peppers, and especially the balsamic.
The next sandwich I got was the '#23,' which came with ham, salami, and provolone with lettuce, tomato, onion, and I think maybe oil and vinegar. This was a true Italian sub and had all the classic ingredients and flavors everyone knows and loves on an Italian sub. It was pretty girthy and hit the spot.
The third sandwich I ate was the 'West Coast,' which was my favorite out of all three. It was a sandwich that once again came with either chicken cutlet or eggplant, and I got the chicken. This one had smashed avocado, swiss, bacon, and mayo. Everything about this was very filling and satisfying. My tastebuds were exploding from the flavors of every bite, and it was phenomenal!
Besides the sandwiches, I also had their 'Potato Salad,' because how can you go to a sandwich shop without getting potato salad?! This one was really good, and had a bit of a sweet and citrusy flavor to it, which was nice. One of the reasons why I like potato salad is because although it tastes the same, there is something about each one that is slightly different and tastes unique. They are all alike but not really. On top of that, Tony Boys is known for their infamous milkshakes, and I had the 'Cookies & Cream' one. It was so good, super creamy, and just spectacular!
At Tony Boys, you can order anything from sandwiches, salads, cheesesteaks, milkshakes, and so much more! Pickup, delivery, and catering are all offered here. Customers can also place family meals, only at the Livingston location. These meals accommodate four to six people and are available after four p.m. Gift cards can be used as gifts and for meal purchases. To join their rewards program, all you have to do is sign up on the website. Also on the website, you can inquire about becoming a franchisee if interested. Tony Boys is the king of sandwiches and milkshakes, and is the next food spot you need to try out!
Rate: 9.25/10